ROBERT A. GARROTT

Professor        Fish and Wildlife Management

Ecology Department--Montana State University

Office Phone:  (406) 994-2270        FAX:  (406) 994-3190        e-mail:  rgarrott@montana.edu

 

 

 

 

 

Dr. Garrott's Home Page

 

 

 

 

 

Graduate Research

Current Projects

Recently Completed Theses

Prospective Student Information

Available Graduate Positions

Funding Partnerships

 

 

Bison and Elk:  Brucellosis Seroprevalence on a Shared Winter Range

Matthew J. Ferrari

 

Cow bison and newborn calfBrucella abortus, a bacterium which causes disease in livestock, wildlife, and humans, has become the target of a large scale eradication program in the wild species of the Greater Yellowstone area. An understanding of the spatial and temporal associations of bison (Bison bison) and elk (Cervus elaphus), the two major vertebrate hosts, is essential in assessing the risk of inter-specific transmission and the long term efficacy of proposed management scenarios to eradicate the disease. The Madison-Firehole drainage of Yellowstone National Park supports high densities of elk and bison during the winter and spring when B. abortus can be shed by females through birth or abortion. I utilized 4,526 telemetry locations of cow elk collected between 1991-1998 and conducted 30 ground censuses of bison between 1997-1998 to assess the distribution and spatial and temporal associations of elk and bison on the winter range. The Madison-Firehole bison winter range is entirely contained within the winter range used by elk. Elk and bison, which normally display significant spatial separation, were found to have high levels of association on the winter range. Increasing snow pack increased the density of bison on the winter range as bison moved into the Madison-Firehole from the Hayden Valley summer range, and deep snow restricted elk to the valley bottoms. Range overlap varied between 53 and 76% (ANOVA, P = 0.09) and tended to increase from December to May. The percent of radiolocations in which instrumented cow elk were =< 100m of bison was 13-30% between April and May, 1991-1998, the peak time of bison calving. Regression analysis indicated that snow water equivalent, a measure of snow depth and density, was positively correlated with elk/bison association and was the strongest predictor of association (P < 0.0001). Despite close association between the two species, a sample of 73 adult cow elk indicated that the prevalence of sero-positive animals in the Madison-Firehole was not significantly different (P > 0.05) from other elk populations that do not associate closely with bison. However the sero-prevalence in the Madison-Firehole was lower (P < 0.05) than the sero-prevalence in populations associated with winter feeding operations. Thus I conclude that the close contact between bison and elk during the winter and spring does not result in increased levels of disease exposure in elk.

 

 

Publication

Ferrari, M.J., and R.A. Garrott.  2002. Bison and elk: brucellosis seroprevalence on a shared winter range. J. Wildl. Manage. 66:1246-1254.

 

Funding

National Park Service

 

The relationship between the percent of monthly elk telemetry locations in which the collared animal was <100 m from the nearest bison (commingling) and the average daily measurement of centimeters of water in the snow pack (snow water equivalent) at the Madison Plateau automated SNOTEL site (elev. 2,362) for each month between December and May 1992-1998 (excluding the winter of 1994-95).

 

State

Location

Year of

Study

Citation

Contact

with Bison

Use of

Feedground

n

Seroprevalence

% (95% CI)

Wyoming

Madison-Firehole

1996-1998

This study

Y

N

73a

3% (0.3%, 10%)

Montana

SW Montana

1997

Rhyan et al., 1997

Y

N

224

0%

Gardiner

1997

Possible

N

721

1% (1%, 2%)

Upper Madison

1997

N

N

389

1% (0%, 2%)

Wyoming

National Elk Refuge

1990,1993,

1995-1997

Bruce Smith pers. comm.

Y

Y

251

25% (20%, 31%)*b

 

State Feedgrounds

 

Herriges et al., 1992

N

Y

 

37% c

Idaho

Rainey Creek

1998

Dave Hunter. pers comm

N

Y

33

0% (16%, 49%)*

Idaho Falls

1992-1993

.

N

N

127

0%

Coeur d'Alene

1990

N

N

57

0%

a Only adult females were sampled in the Madison-Firehole.

b The prevalence rate for the National Elk Refuge was calculated as the total number of sero-positive animals divided by the total number of animals sampled during the years of 1990, 1993, and 1995-97.

c The prevalence rate and sample size for individual years (Year, p, N) was: (1990, 0.15, 100), (1993, 0.32, 41), (1995, 0.41, 17), (1996, 0.35, 62), (1997, 0.22, 31).

 

Seroprevalence rates for antibodies to B. abortus in 8 elk populations (males and females) in Wyoming, Montana, and Idaho and summary data for Wyoming state feedgrounds (Herriges et al. 1992). Clopper-Pearson 95% confidence intervals (Casella and Berger 1990) are presented in parentheses. All populations are from the Greater Yellowstone area except Coeur D’Alene, ID. Prevalence rates greater than that of the Madison-Firehole (P<0.01, Fisher’s Exact test) are indicated by an asterisk.